Thinking Anglicans

St Pauls' Cathedral: Wednesday morning reports

Updated 1 pm Wednesday

According to Episcopal Cafe Ruth Gledhill and Fay Schlesinger in The Times are reporting [subscription only] that Canon Dr. Giles Fraser will resign if the Cathedral moves to evict Occupy London protesters:

…Dr Giles Fraser, who is responsible for the cathedral’s relations with the financial institutions of the City of London, is understood to be prepared to quit should it take legal action against the 200 tents forming an increasingly permanent-looking settlement on its land.

…. A resignation from Dr Fraser would make him a martyr for the anti-capitalist cause and prove hugely embarrassing to the cathedral and the Church. If the cathedral does not try to oust the protesters, however, it will be forced into the humiliating position of reopening with the tents still in place, or remaining closed for months — putting events such as the Remembrance Day services at risk and losing the cathedral about £16,000 a day in tourist revenue.

Update The BBC reports that Giles Fraser’s resignation threat relates to “use of force” rather than the taking of legal action to remove the protestors.

Telegraph St Paul’s Cathedral protest: Blitz landmark closed because you might trip over guy rope by Victoria Ward, Richard Alleyne and Tim Ross

At the height of the Blitz, the relentless pounding of London by Luftwaffe bombers forced St Paul’s Cathedral to close its doors for a total of four days.

But today (Weds) health and safety fears about people tripping over tent guy ropes and blocked emergency exits have achieved what Hitler did not, and shut it for a fifth day.

The cathedral has been criticised after it released a full list of the health and safety concerns that has been used as justification for closing it for the longest time in living memory.

Mark Field, Tory MP for Cities of London and Westminster – in which the cathedral sits – said they were “spurious health and safety excuses” and called for them to be ignored.

“There never seemed to be any substance to the health and safety reasons for the closure. It was a nuclear option and it has been a monumental own goal,” he said…

14
Leave a Reply

avatar
3000
14 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
12 Comment authors
MarkBrunsonMalcolm French+Laurence RobertsSusannahJCF Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of
JCF
Guest
JCF

[“tent guy ropes”? I feel you Brits and we Yanks are being “divided by a common language” again. O_o]

Huzzah for Fr Giles, if true. Imagine, a member of the Establishment of the Established Church who seems to Get It! (y’know, the Gospel that is)

Frank
Guest
Frank

Provide water, food and portable toilet facilities to the protesters. And of course, re-open the cathedral!

John Bowles
Guest
John Bowles

According to Damian Thompson, the Daily Telegraph initiated an investigation and found most of the tents lying empty, a discovery that has infuriated the ‘protestors’, The sooner the police come in the better if it would lead to the welcome resignation of the ‘martyred’ Canon. His initial statements did more then anything to lead to the present impasse.

Erika Baker
Guest
Erika Baker

Why would it invalidate the protest if some people went home to sleep?

Wouldn’t it be helpful if people engaged with what the protest is actually about rather than try to ridicule it and malign those protesting?

These tactics say much more about those who refuse to engage than about the member of the movement.

Thank God for Twitter and YouTube to get a real picture of what it’s all about.

Tom Danielson
Guest
Tom Danielson

I can’t help but be struck at the difference between St Paul’s handling of this situation, and the way the Episcopal churches in New York City have handled this, Trinity Wall Street for example (www.trinitywallstreet.org). A great opportunity to show young people in Britain that the church understands and sympathizes with their problems has been wasted. The dean needs to wake up.

Pat O'Neill
Guest
Pat O'Neill

Has it occurred to the Telegraph that the tents might be empty because the inhabitants are out protesting? Or raising money? Or working at whatever jobs they might have?

Freddy Crabbe
Guest
Freddy Crabbe

Do the empty tents mirror empty churches?

Simon
Guest
Simon

I agree with Tom Danielson. Trinity Wall street inviting people in to dialogue is what churches should be doing. St Paul’s has handled it disastrously. They have missed an opportunity to chair a national debate on a topic of the greatest importance.

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

’empty tents’ ?

My bed-room will (usually / often) be found to be empty during the day too

JCF
Guest
JCF

Does “John Bowles” write for The Onion or ChristWire? (I keep being reminded of Poe’s Law! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law)

Susannah
Guest
Susannah

A critique that highlights the ‘fix’ the Cathedral has got itself into, first telling the protestors to go on ‘health and safety’ grounds, but failing to define what the dtails were so the protestors could address them; secondly closing the cathedral when openness and dialogue could have achieved today’s decision to re-open before they even closed… And then the whole impression this gives, along with the continued call to ‘go’, even when the protestors have co-operated on the health and safety grounds, that the Cathedral is more anxious to align with wealthy neighbours who happen to be its donors, than… Read more »

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

They could invite the camp of those bearing witness to sleep IN the church on these increasingly cold , wet nights

Malcolm French+
Guest

Perhaps Giles Fraser should resign anyway, simply to avoid being tarred with the ineptitude of his colleagues.

MarkBrunson
Guest

I would say the empty tents represent the empty lives of the modern man, constantly caught between the market of the busy street and the hope of a higher being symbolized by the cathedral, which hope becomes a symbol of oppression as it looms over the helpless tents themselves, dwarfing their very significance.

***

Let’s not get into symbolism – it’s the arena of prophets and critics, and can easily be turned to mean anything you want it to.