Thinking Anglicans

Report questions the freedom of Christians in the UK

Updated Tuesday evening

The All-Party Parliamentary Group named Christians in Parliament has published a report titled Clearing the Ground, and subtitled it: Preliminary report into the freedom of Christians in the UK.

This report and related documents can be found at the Evangelical Alliance website, here.

Writing in advance of the report’s publication, Jim Dobbin MP and Gary Streeter MP said in the Telegraph on Sunday that: We need reforms to protect the rights of Christians. There is an accompanying news story Britain failing to stand up for Christians, say MPs.

In the Mail on Sunday Jonathan Petre reported this story as Harriet Harman’s law on equality ‘is anti-Christian’ and unacceptable.

Today’s Independent has Committee claims rights laws leave out Christians by Nina Lakhani.

The BBC had Equality law ‘should be extended to cover faith’.

Today’s responses to the report so far include:

Ekklesia Report alleging discrimination against Christians ‘confused’

British Humanist Association British Humanist Association refutes findings of ‘Clearing the Ground’ report

Update

More responses:

Andrew Brown Cif belief Are Christians being marginalised?

Are Christians their own worst enemies in Britain today? This question is raised with unusual frankness in a couple of paragraphs of an all-party parliamentary group’s report into Christians and discrimination, which was launched yesterday.

It contains a really quite startling attack on Christian campaign groups:

“The actions of some campaign groups can discredit the Church in the UK and result in perceptions that Christians are seeking unfair exemptions. By bringing highly emotive cases to the fore, they also can add to the feeling among Christians that they are more marginalised than they actually are.

“On some occasions we perceive that campaigning becomes inflammatory or even counterproductive to Christian freedoms. This is due to factors such as: the strategically unwise selection of cases; a distorted presentation of facts for manipulation of the media; and most alarmingly, the deliberate misinforming of the church constituency in order to motivate support.”

But the report also maintains that there have been cases in which Christians have been unfairly treated, usually as a result of ignorance in the wider culture, rather than malevolence; and it demands a reshaping of the Equality and Human Rights Commission, which evangelical Christians loathe…

National Secular Society Christian discrimination report is just another call for special privileges

17
Leave a Reply

avatar
3000
17 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
David ShepherdFather Ron SmithDennisPat O'NeillLaurence Roberts Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of
Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

more thinly veiled gay bashing ?

These priveleged wailing tories are a disgrace.

I want to distance myself from their ‘complaints’ after 60+ years as a Christian- do these people even participate in any form of Christianity ?

I have only ever had my freedom removed as a gay person and they hope to revert to ‘the good old days’ asap.

You wouldnt find a Jesus signing up to this BS.

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

oh please ! – this stuff doesnt even need decoding:

‘Religious illiteracy has led to legal restrictions on the way that faith can be expressed. Recent changes have
compelled Christians to provide services that they had never previously offered and which may be contrary to their beliefs.’

We all know it means services to lgbt people.

These groups though mealy-mouthed have vile intentions.

They are mealy-mouthed as a political ploy.

As for religiously illiterate ! …

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

Ah, they wish to use more insulting language more often ! Now that’s what I call religious literacy ! • The 1986 Public Order Act, and specifically Section 5, places the bar too low through its prohibition on insulting language. • The policing of the Public Order Act and other legislation demonstrates a lack of understanding of what is a legitimate expression of Christian belief. • Government departments handle religious belief in a complex and confused manner and lack I almost pity this pathetic small and unrepresentative group as they seek to bolster their egos and fight for all that… Read more »

Craig Nelson
Guest
Craig Nelson

The BBC report says the equality law should “cover faith”. Of course it already does – religion and belief are one of the protected characteristics and there are extensive religious exemptions in the legislations to cater for those whose faith require discrimination. As to the report – Ekklesia says it all really. I think the report was probably written by feeding various Lawyers Christian Fellowship and Christian Institute press releases into a computer and pressing a button – out comes the report. People should look at the narrow, self selected membership of the “committee” before reading the “report”. As regards… Read more »

karen macqueen+_
Guest

This report, “Clearing the Ground,” can only further damage religious groups in England, especially those who call themselves “Christian”. The authors of this report seem to have learned nothing from the history of institutional Christianity, which, though notable for many and profound works of charity, is also characterized by egregious persecution against scientists and humanists, and appalling violence against those with whom they disagree, especially against women, children and LGBT persons and families. These groups apply the name “Christian” to themselves, thereby smearing the name of other Christians and Churches who do not agree with them. In the United States,… Read more »

Mary Marriott
Guest
Mary Marriott

Not a good day for spiritual religion.

And yet how could true spiritual religion ever be finished off ? It’s like saying the golden rule, the sermon on the mount or love between people could be murdered in the people’s breasts.

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

They’ll have Jesus turning in his grave Kirsty — because, for them he hasn’t risen yet! They’ve made sure that wopping stone has blocked his exit! Just like tory policies are endangering the well being of low income families, elders, ill people, disabled people …….blocking their exit from poverty, illness and tory-libdem broken promises

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

American Christians also enjoin the battle for Christian freedoms :

http://queeringthechurch.com/2012/02/27/religious-freedom-baptists-oppose-gay-marriage-ban/

Pat O'Neill
Guest
Pat O'Neill

I find it hard to understand how a nation with an established Christian church can be said to need special protections for Christians.

Father Ron Smith
Guest

This is just one more way of the conservative wing of the Church of England trying to establish its authority as Establishment Church. This is surely no longer feasible in the context of the ‘freedom of religion’ ethos of the multi-cultural society of the united Kingdom – where even the Monarch is now known, at least colloquially, as the ‘Defender of Faiths’ – not just of the C.of E. For Lord Carey and his friends to assert the pre-eminence of his sola-Scriptura point of view as the fulcrum of the English legal system, is hardly consistent with the role and… Read more »

David Shepherd
Guest

‘Which of you, by being anxious, can add one moment to his lifespan?’ (Matt. 6:27) Certain qualities, such as lifespan, are largely determined by genetics and, regardless of our best efforts, at the mercy of divine providence. Such characteristics should not be a cause of fear and guilt. Beyond these demonstrably pre-determined traits, the gospel challenges every aspect of human behaviour, bar none, with the call for change. All other limits on marital affinity are applied without exemption. There is no room for special pleading. No aspect of human personality, however intractable, is off limits. The true prophet Jeremiah showed… Read more »

Dennis
Guest
Dennis

Mr. Shepherd, indeed, but it does seem sad that so few of the traditionalists have been supportive of efforts to expose the fruitless deeds of homophobia and other acts of darkness. There have been recent studies in neuroscience and genetics showing that a tendency toward conservative views about social order might be congenitally predisposed. Nonetheless, I appreciate your reminder that those who are against the recognition of the legitimate partnerships of same sex couples cannot plead that they were born with a bend toward bigotry. We need to encourage them to leave the errors of the 13th century and recognize… Read more »

David Shepherd
Guest

Dennis: That would all make sense if those studies to which you refer (and those claiming gay genetic/psychological determinism) produced established scientific facts, rather than promising lines of enquiry. If there is no variation to the polarised view that the mere challenge towards any behaviour constitutes a phobia of it, I guess that, in thrall as I am to other Levitical pronouncements, I’m also incestophobic (not thereby implying a ‘slippery slope’ connection). I also break out into a terrible rash at the repeated mention of the all-too-clever ‘shellfish and mixed fibres’ argument (Howbeit, therein lies a cure for my insomnia!)… Read more »

Father Ron Smith
Guest

David, I wonder if you are really aware that Jesus condensed ‘all the Law and the Prophets’ into the New Commandment – “that you love one another as I have loved you” – This is my commandment! Jesus did not cling to shibboleths, as you appear to be doing.

David Shepherd
Guest

Ron,

It’s a pity that you only target as shibboleths those ideas that challenge your ‘progessive’ world-view, Especially since state-enforced *multi-culturalism* (that you espouse in an earlier post) has failed so spectacularly in Britain.

Father Ron Smith
Guest

Have you, David, personally experienced the failure?

David Shepherd
Guest

Our failure’s only remedy:

‘It is a trustworthy statement, deserving full acceptance, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, among whom I am foremost of all.’ (1 Tim. 1:15)

‘The servant therefore fell down, and worshiped him, saying, Lord, have patience with me, and I will pay you all.’ (Matt.18:26)

‘Not the labours of my hands,
Could fulfil thy laws demands,
Could my tears forever flow,
Or my zeal no respite know,
All for sin could not atone,
Thou must save,
And Thou alone!’