Thinking Anglicans

opinion

Nicola Hulks writes for She Loves magazine about When The Church Said No.

Kirk Smith writes for the Episcopal Café that Ancient manuscript will influence new archbishop.

Iain McLean writes for Politics in Spires about The utility function of Celestine V and the election of Pope Francis.

Christopher Howse writes for The Telegraph about St Francis as the Pope’s patron.

Giles Fraser writes in The Guardian that I bang my head against the wall when evangelicals turn Jesus into Cheesus.

19
Leave a Reply

avatar
3000
19 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
15 Comment authors
Erika BakerCounterlightDavid KeenJonathan Jenningsdavid Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of
Cynthia
Guest
Cynthia

Ouch. I’m a bit embarrassed for the Bishop of Arizona, believing that Christianity only came to the UK via Augustine. For the record, plenty of us Yanks do know about the presence of Celtic Christianity before Augustine…

Jeremy
Guest
Jeremy

Consider too the martyrs of Roman Britain, Saint Alban among them.

Old Father William
Guest
Old Father William

As someone who holds a doctorate in English Church history, Bishop Smith is surely familiar with the Celtic Church. I don’t think he meant to imply that it never existed!

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

Professor McLean’s paper is so thoughtful, scholarly and godly it both informed and touched me. The historical research, the theoretical basis (which I but dimly understood),the theology of Holy Spirit guidance; and hearing of Pope Celestine V’s wisdom and holiness were deeply affecting, and increased (almost paradoxically) a sense of greater reverence for the holy see, as somehow, ‘an instrument of Thy peace’, or something.

Perhaps, I am letting myself be carried away. I don’t know.

But to be lost in God would be everything.

sjh
Guest
sjh

Bishop Smith does not mention the UK which did not exist in Anglo Saxon times. He mentioned only England, as is historically correct. Augustine brought Christianity to the Anglo Saxon kingdoms which practised Germanic heathenism, not the Celtic nations which already had Christian churches

Cynthia
Guest
Cynthia

OK, sjh. Cornwall wasn’t Celtic or part of England? Just asking, because I saw a lot of Celtic crosses there…

Old Father William
Guest
Old Father William

Giles Fraser’s article remnds me of one of Robert Farrar Capon’s books (read them!) where he compares us to someone who has driven off the road into a ditch during a blizzard. Jesus comes along in his enormous tow-truck, but, instead of towing us out of the ditch, he gets out of his truck, enters our car, embraces us, and dies with us in the cold. This is Jesus, not Cheesus.

american piskie
Guest
american piskie

Cynthia,

Cornwall *isn’t* (except in the most trivial sense) part of England even now.

sjh
Guest
sjh

Cornwall is even today regarded as one of the Celtic nations, has its own Celtic language, now being revived, and was not originally part of the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms in the sixth century. Wessex only went up to Devon.

Stephen De Silva
Guest
Stephen De Silva

Bishop Kirk Smith knows Saint Alban well – he has preached at St Albans Cathedral on several occasions. He is well aware that there was a Christian presence in England before Augustine – I think he’s talking more about the “institutional” church.

rjb
Guest
rjb

“Celtic Christianity” – like the “Celts” themselves – has a bigger presence in popular culture than it does in modern historical scholarship. As the medievalist Edward James has complained “the ‘Celtic Church’ […] has often carried associations that are foreign to the historical reality. In the nineteenth century it could be imagined that the Irish, Welsh, and Pictish resistance to Christianity as it was taught by Rome was a heroic resistance to centralisation imposed from Rome, a proto-Protestant desire to live an apostolic life without interference from a self-styled head of the Church. [….] This is clearly an anachronistic way… Read more »

davigoss
Guest
davigoss

“Celtic Christianity” – What about St Aidan who came, at the invitation of King (St) Oswald to evangelise Northumbria – and under whose name (after his death) there were those who rallied at the Synod of Whitby to retain the “Celtic” method of dating Easter, in preference to the Roman method? – I am not an expert in these matters, but am just asking the question.

Laurence Roberts
Guest
Laurence Roberts

rjb – paid *anghofio Cymru / please don’t *forget Wales !

* however fashionable.

Wales has been more successful in retaining the language than the other parts of the British Isles.

Jean Mayland
Guest
Jean Mayland

Up here in Norhumberland we are quite convinced that Celtic Christianity was a reality- and actually still is important today Those Norhern Saints like Aidan,Oswald, Cutherbert and Hilda are very much alive.

I invite you to go to Heavenfield where Oswald set up the cross , defeated the pagan king and re-established Christianity The little Church there is never ever locked and the atmosphere of prayer is very powerful.

david
Guest
david

Old Father William – I dont see much hope in that Jesus you describe – that cannot actually deliver you from the pit – Jesus did deliver me from the pit, not die in the pit with me – I am certain he also shed tears for me that I should be in the far far country that had so many pits. In life, he often sends the tow-truck man to get you out. The resurrection is the sign of Hope – death has been defeated; the work of the devil ultimately destroyed. To extend your analogy, if Jesus got… Read more »

Jonathan Jennings
Guest
Jonathan Jennings

Well said, Jean! And there’s a character about Christianity in the North which is highly resistant still to anything being imposed from outside. David Jenkins articulated this so well …

David Keen
Guest
David Keen

Good response to Giles Frasers piece at http://godandpoliticsuk.org/2013/03/23/giles-frasers-attack-on-evangelical-christians-is-both-ignorant-and-unecessary/ I see a fair few evangelicals and not many of them fit his description, so it’s either a London thing, or a straw man.

Counterlight
Guest
Counterlight

“…see a fair few evangelicals and not many of them fit his description, so it’s either a London thing, or a straw man.”

I was born and raised in Texas and lived for many years in the Midwest part of the USA. I spent much of my life in regions dominated by Evangelicals. I think Giles is spot on.

Erika Baker
Guest
Erika Baker

I think there is a regrettable tendency for some British evangelicals to go the same way as their American counterparts, but that is not really what evangelicalism is about in this country. I don’t know if people across the pond can get BBC iplayer but there was a very good radio program on Radio 4 only a couple of days ago: Beyond Belief – what is evangelical. http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01rg1gy/Beyond_Belief_Evangelical/ Within all forms of churchmanship, there are highly intelligent and mindnumbingly unintelligent expressions. To dismiss a whole sector as shallow is no more helpful than Richard Dawkins representing all religious people as… Read more »