Wednesday, 10 November 2010

Pastoral Letter from the Bishop of Ebbsfleet

To complete a trilogy of pastoral letters, here is one from the Bishop of Ebbsfleet.

The Bishop of Ebbsfleet’s Pastoral Letter – November 2010

Bishop Andrew’s Final Pastoral Letter

FIRST, I must apologise for this letter appearing late: I have delayed writing it until 9th November, the day after I announced my resignation from the See of Ebbsfleet, and the first anniversary of Anglicanorum cœtibus. Today is also the anniversary of Bishop John Richards’ death. When he became Bishop in 1994 many thought that he would be the one and only Bishop of Ebbsfleet. Who would have thought that he would have several successors – two so far? Bishop John was a fine man and I pray that he will rest in peace and share in the glory of the Resurrection.

My resignation takes effect on 31st December but, for bishops who become a Roman Catholic, custom requires that we cease public ministry forthwith. I foresaw how difficult this would be and it was for that reason that I arranged Study Leave, which began a month ago and lasts until the end of the year. I am extremely grateful for the countless messages of goodwill I have received. My farewell service is at 12 noon on 27th November at St John’s, New Hinksey, Oxford. I hope that some of you can be there.

Until the resignation was announced, I was careful not to recommend to anyone, or to any parish, how they should react to Anglicanorum cœtibus, the Holy See’s response to our appeal to Rome for help. Writing recently to laity in Oxford Forward in Faith who had expressed an interest in remaining in the Church of England whatever happens, my office duly sent them details of the Society of St Wilfred and St Hilda. Writing to those interested in the Ordinariate of England and Wales, I promised to hand on their details, with their permission, to the lay organisers. I hope something similarly even-handed happens in every diocese of the Church of England. As I have explained in the last three Pastoral Letters, this is a time for prayerful discernment. The Holy Spirit is at work in the Church, not at our beck and call, but changing and transforming us and our communities. The pioneering Ordinariate groups, when they come into being, will be ‘fresh expressions of church’, mostly new, missionary congregations, seeking to bring people to the fullness of the Catholic Faith and to advance the work of the Kingdom.

It has been hard – and it will continue to be hard – to leave many of you behind. The relationship of a bishop with his people is that of a father and, of all the titles, ‘father’ is the one to cherish. To no longer be the father of the clergy, the people, and the parishes is a real bereavement. I love you and I miss you. Had the Ebbsfleet project succeeded, we would all have become a local church, not unlike an Ordinariate, but within the Church of England, and seeking unity corporately with the Holy See, a fulfilment of the ARCIC discussions these last forty years. That was our vision, and it was not to be. Those who see a future for Ebbsfleet need another bishop with a different vision.

Yet amidst the bereavement is also intense joy. The Ordinariate is not something that can be joined corporately. Like the Walsingham coach, we have to climb on board one by one. In the queue for the coach, and on the coach, the pilgrimage group are all together, with their pastor. A couple of dozen of these coaches will be on the road very soon in Southern England, and I shall be on one of them. Other coaches will join the pilgrimage later: some people are already making bookings. Those joining the pilgrimage – a ramshackle caravan of pilgrims stretching across the wastelands into the distance – are full of joy and hope. Their enthusiasm and faith are contagious. Though I have had chance to visit only four of the groups, lay leaders of other groups have been in touch. So too have the clergy who have been acting as chaplains of the groups, amidst their other responsibilities.

Never far from the back of my mind are the Farewell Discourses of Jesus in St John’s Gospel. After all, to follow Christ, even at our lowly level, means being prepared to walk on ahead, face the dangers and difficulties, and trust that those left behind will be cared for. There is no vainglory here. I am quite sure, faced with the Passion, I would have run away, like the other disciples. I too would have denied even knowing Jesus, and left it to the holy women to be constant and strong. But, looking through the Farewell Discourses, there is not only Jesus going ahead to prepare a place but also the promise of a fresh outpouring of the Holy Spirit (John 14). Jesus is the True Vine and, cut off from him, we can do nothing but wither and be thrown into the fire and burned (John 15). His new commandment is to love one another. There are two musical settings of these words by sixteenth century composers, Sheppard and Tallis, working in the heat of the reformation battle. They were Catholics but bravely setting texts for the new Reformation Church. ‘By this shall men know that ye are my disciples, if ye have love one for another’. The work of the Spirit is to guide us into all the truth (John 16:13) and to glorify the Father and the Son. Thus our sorrow will be turned into joy. We learn of the gift of Peace, which, amidst the tribulation of the world is found only in Christ. Finally Jesus prays for the gift of Unity (John 17). It is that gift of Unity, I believe, which is offered to us, and through us eventually to all separated Christians, in the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum coetibus. It is because it is a gift of the Holy Spirit, abiding in his Church, that I believe I must accept it and invite others to come with me on the journey. The Church gathers round, and maintains its unity in communion with, the successor of Peter.

I disown and renounce nothing that I have done in Jesus’ name: God is faithful. But I am now laying aside my bishopric. Self-emptying (kenosis) is hard – harder than any of us can manage in our own strength – but it is basic to being a disciple, as the gospels constantly remind us. Everyone on the journey has to do some laying aside. But we pray, in Cowper’s words, echoing St John of the Cross: ‘The dearest idol I have known, Whate’er that idol be, Help me to tear it from Thy throne, And worship only Thee’.

It is a Parting of Friends. I was mindful of that on the feast of Blessed John Henry Newman, 9th October, when I went off to Littlemore to join in the Newman Mass there. This time we must do everything – better than we managed 150 years ago and 15 years ago – to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace (Ephesians 4:3). Let us leave aside our squabbles and let God work in our midst.

May God bless and keep you as you faithfully seek to serve him.

+ Andrew

Posted by Peter Owen on Wednesday, 10 November 2010 at 10:34pm GMT | TrackBack
You can make a Permalink to this if you like
Categorised as: Church of England

"My resignation takes effect on 31st December but, for bishops who become a Roman Catholic, custom requires that we cease public ministry forthwith. I foresaw how difficult this would be and it was for that reason that I arranged Study Leave, which began a month ago and lasts until the end of the year."


"My final act as a Bishop will be to celebrate the Mass at Gordon Square on the eve of Christ the King, Saturday 20th November at 12 noon."

Compare and contrast

Posted by: John Roch on Wednesday, 10 November 2010 at 11:30pm GMT

"The Holy Spirit is at work in the Church, not at our beck and call, but changing and transforming us and our communities."

I couldn't agree more. Women are now being accepted as full members of the Church as (more gradually) are gays and lesbians. The Church is finally realizing its potential. It's taken nearly 2,000 years, but I believe it's becoming what it was meant to be.

Posted by: Doug on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 12:21am GMT

Thanks, Andrew. I trust that we will remain friends in the Lord. You are right: the Holy Spirit is alive and well and bending over backwards. Kenosis is the heart of it all. God bless....

Posted by: joe cassidy on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 12:43am GMT

honest and heartfelt, i thought. blessings to him on his journey.

Posted by: trooper on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 4:06am GMT

I'm interested in the notion that there is a 'See of Ebbsfleet'. Can somebody explain, please? A See has to have a bishop's throne and thus a cathedral, doesn't it? I didn't think suffragan bishop's had their own cathedrals but were appointed to assist the diocesan bishop to administer his See. And I didn't think you could have two Sees occupying the same geographical space. Anybody? Thanks.

Posted by: Terence Dear on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 10:10am GMT

Yes, Terrence but when you think about it, a sea and a sandbank (Ebbsfleet) do often go together, under providence.

Seriously, Andrew and the others seem to have so much energy and get up and go ! Impressive.

Posted by: Laurence Roberts on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 11:40am GMT

Suffragan sees in England were established by the Suffragan Bishops Act 1534 (see -- where it taks about the Sees established for these suffragan bishops; a list since added to incidentally!)

This is absolutely consistent with the idea of one bishop one see. In the case of a suffragan, this is a 'titular see', but it retains the notion that (a) a bishop is the bishop of a place, and (b) that you cannot have more than one bishop n the same place. Before the Reformation, these assistant bishops took their titles from sees in lands which had been occupied by the infidel :-) and thus no longer had a Christian congregation needing a bishop. At the Reformation, when the Crown did not claim the right to nominate bishops to these foreign sees, the system of suffragan bishoprics was put in place to provide assistance to the English diocesan bishops. These suffragans took (as they still do in England) their titles from another town in the diocese to which they are appointed to assist.

The US idea that a suffragan bishop shares the title, the see, of the diocesan bishop does not exist in England. A suffragan bishop has his own, titular, see, though as you note, he has no cathedral, and no throne.

Suffragan bishops are appointed to help minister to the diocese -- we need to distinguish between the 'diocese', the 'see' and the 'bishopric' here.

Of course, at one level al this is mere pedantry, and no one's salvation depends upon it. On the other hand, it does mean that Bishop Andrew is quite correct to refer to the See of Ebbsfleet. Just as long neither he nor anyone else assumes that there is necessarily any jurisdiction that pertains to that see.

Posted by: Simon Kershaw on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 11:42am GMT

Thanks, Simon. Very interesting. Much appreciated.

Posted by: Terence Dear on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 1:14pm GMT

Dear Friends,

Why is it that the religious are the last ones to consider the equality and worth of all persons, male/female, jew/gentile, poor/rich, gay/straight? No matter the esoteric language, the lofty rhetoric, or the well stated apologies, he and the rest are afraid of getting cooties and want to continue the paternal system of self affirmation and subordination of the other.

Posted by: Randall J. Keeney on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 9:35pm GMT

Note: In England there is also a distinction to be made between Suffragan bishops and Area Bishops (appointed under a Diocesan Area Scheme). The PEVs have to be related in appropriate ways to each diocese in which they operate - but they are suffragans of the archbishops and treated effectively as 'provincial suffragans'.

Hence the resignations of two bishops via Lambeth, and a third via London as a diocesan suffragan.

No doubt Simon K will correct any technical errors in the above - if in doubt ask the expert.

Posted by: Mark Bennet on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 10:57pm GMT

"Stand not upon the order of your going, but GO, at once!" - William Shakespeare -

Posted by: Father Ron Smith on Thursday, 11 November 2010 at 11:19pm GMT

A lovely sermon from +Andrew. We are all actually 'One in Christ'. The only trouble is, some of us haven't even begun to accept the fact.

Perhaps when we begin to practise the irrational, all-embracing LOVE of God, who 'so loved the world...'that Unity may be recognised amongst us.

Posted by: Father Ron Smith on Sunday, 14 November 2010 at 9:35am GMT
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Please note that comments are limited to 400 words. Comments that are longer than 400 words will not be approved.

Cookies are used to remember your personal information between visits to the site. This information is stored on your computer and used to refill the text boxes on your next visit. Any cookie is deleted if you select 'No'. By ticking 'Yes' you agree to this use of a cookie by this site. No third-party cookies are used, and cookies are not used for analytical, advertising, or other purposes.