Comments: Archbishop's Advent letter to Anglican Primates

It's a really good letter. Especially the bit about not letting our differences keep us from getting on with the work of the Gospel. I don't know who started the Indaba process, but it really seems to be taking root and having a positive impact on growing in love, even if we can't agree. And that opens the doors and windows to working together, especially to bring compassion, food, water, medicine, and nurturing to those in need.

This is the path, not the covenant or hierarchical efforts to bring the liberal churches in line with the conservative ones. Hopefully we can put that all behind us and move forward.

Posted by Cynthia at Thursday, 6 December 2012 at 7:42am GMT

Cynthia. It's all very well to talk about living together with difference', but it take two to tango. I doubt if you could ever get an intransigent anti-women's-ordination person to live with women in charge. Why, they even demand separate episcope!

Posted by Father Ron Smith at Thursday, 6 December 2012 at 10:18am GMT

Cynthia, I wish I could agree, but it is not a really good letter.

In it Dr. Williams continues his basic mistake of trying to please all sides.

Most objectionably, he further encourages those who would try to make the Anglican Communion into one structure. This letter is no retreat from that project.

Particularly troubling is the phrase "the truth is that our Communion has never been the sort of Church that looks for one central authority.... [I]n the Church we have to have several points of reference for the organising of our common life."

This is archiepiscopal doubletalk.

The "truth" is that our Communion has never been any sort of Church at all.

"[S]everal points of reference for the organising of our common life?" What is being referred to here?

At present, each province "organises" itself.

Posted by Jeremy at Thursday, 6 December 2012 at 12:30pm GMT

It is incredible to see the spin that George Conger and then Kendall Harmon's brigade put on this letter. They say that ++Rowan has - apparently - conceded that the Anglican Communion has become 'corrupted'. Are they reading a different Advent letter? Being a 'conservative' is one thing; being creative with the facts is quite another, and what ++Rowan actually said was:
"Despite many questions about how our decisions about doctrine and mutual responsibility are made in the Communion, and some challenges to the various ‘Instruments of Communion’, the truth is that our Communion has never been the sort of Church that looks for one central authority. This doesn’t mean that we are not concerned with truth or holiness or consistency. It simply acknowledges that all forms of human power and discipline can become corrupted, and that in the Church we have to have several points of reference for the organising of our common life so that none of them can go without challenge or critique from the others."
Robert Runcie said the same thing many years ago, and it is an excellent summary of why many of us are Anglicans in the first place. If George Conger and Kendall Harmon and their followers want a central authority, why aren't they taking up the Pope's kind offer?

Posted by Andrew Godsall at Thursday, 6 December 2012 at 4:38pm GMT

Fa. Smith, I hear you, especially the bit about the intransigent people demanding a separate episcopate. That is exactly what happened in TEC, in the face of intransigent people who could not be appeased in any way, the rest started voting their conscience and that's how we got so liberal. And faced schism, South Carolina is the last gasp. And this is the crossroads for CoE now.

However, between provinces in the Anglican Communion, it is possible to coexist and agree to disagree. It's especially possible if no one tries to exercise power over another province. Power really is the key. No one should have it, not even the ABC. That makes us talk instead, and it looks as if the Indaba process is helping.

Jeremy, I appreciate your parsing of "archiepiscopal doubletalk" for me. My ear for that is not keen. And sometimes us Yanks don't pick up on it all, even me, having lived in England for a small bit. If you're right, then I guess the prayer is that the new ABC exercise more humility and perhaps more savvy in the job. It does look like he's got his hands full at home.

Posted by Cynthia at Thursday, 6 December 2012 at 10:06pm GMT
Post a comment

Remember personal info?

Please note that comments are limited to 400 words. Comments that are longer than 400 words will not be approved.

Cookies are used to remember your personal information between visits to the site. This information is stored on your computer and used to refill the text boxes on your next visit. Any cookie is deleted if you select 'No'. By ticking 'Yes' you agree to this use of a cookie by this site. No third-party cookies are used, and cookies are not used for analytical, advertising, or other purposes.