The Times Ruth Gledhill Bishops want signatures taken off anti-gay letter
Telegraph Jonathan Petre Attack on archbishop rebounds on rebels
Guardian Stephen Bates Archbishop disowns attack on Williams
and a leader column, Sex and schism
Church Times Letter from the Global South
The site that originally published the letter has added this note:
(GSA Admin note:
This letter is posted here for the benefit of those who attended the Encounter and the people they represent. Archbishop Rowan William’s talk and sharing was appreciated and well received with deep gratitude, though as expected, it will raise some questions as well, some which were conveyed by the delegates to the Primates. This letter is a part of the on-going process of dialogue between Global South and the Archbishop of Canterbury and should not be interpreted in other unhelpful ways.)
And Ekklesia has Anglican Primates deny attack on Archbishop of Canterbury and also Global leaders query Church of England state link
Posted by Simon Sarmiento on Friday, 18 November 2005 at 8:18am GMTThis is a big scandal, isn't it :=0
Posted by: Göran Koch-Swahne on Friday, 18 November 2005 at 12:58pm GMTI'm surprised that +Phillipines and Indian +Ocean are among the signers.
Posted by: Tuck-Leong on Friday, 18 November 2005 at 3:02pm GMTThe problem seems to have been that the ABC was preoccupied with the opening of the new General Synod and so did not have a chance to respond before the letter was made public and the media put their own hyperbolic spin on things.
There is an old saw that ’silence implies assent', and none of those present was p[repared to disassociate himself from the statement as it was being drafted. Nevertheless it is clear that some of those at the Egypt meeting were not aware that this response to the ABC’s answers to questions was going to be made public, though since the original questions and his answers were public one might be excused for assuming that the response to those answers would be public too.
Posted by: F LABELLUM on Friday, 18 November 2005 at 5:21pm GMTCould Father Libellum give his sources for this?
Posted by: Göran Koch-Swahne on Friday, 18 November 2005 at 7:31pm GMTI accept Archbishop Hanford's picture of this -- I've been to many meetings at which things have been said or done with which I've disagreed without feeling the need to make a fuss about it. The assumption of assent was clearly wrong.
Posted by: Tobias S Haller BSG on Friday, 18 November 2005 at 10:39pm GMTThis is a big scandal, isn't it :=0 -Goran
At least that is what that section of the press wants us to believe. pick one word 'evil' from over 2000 words and picture it proceeding out of the mouths of archbishops pointing with accusing fingers.
-sorry wrong picture. The Global south web used one that showed them together with some edibles on the table.
The scandal is the failed attempt to divert people from the contents of the response which many have commented truly represents them
Posted by: Tunde on Saturday, 19 November 2005 at 5:33pm GMTTunde wrote: "the contents of the response which many have commented truly represents them"
Many indeed (what is it that you want to "prove" by the word "many"?) but unfortunately not all of the "signatories"...
And that is a Scandal.
Posted by: Göran Koch-Swahne on Saturday, 19 November 2005 at 6:50pm GMTThank you, your Grace, for coming....
We were pleased by your positive comments regarding ...
We are grateful for your willingness to answer the many questions that our members wished to ask, and we hope that you may take time to answer some of those that were not mentioned in the session....
We welcome your pastoral example of coming amongst us as presiding Primate of the Anglican Communion. We recognize the limitations on your office, as the Communion has few legal structures. We agree with you that a Communion Covenant is needed....
Once again, we wish to commend you for taking the effort to be with us in Egypt....
With gratitude and fraternal greetings.....
Waiting for a conservative to spin the above (and other appreciative words) to picture the GS primates cringing before ++Rowan. That might make some (esp. ++Akinola) dissociate themselves from the document.
Posted by: Tunde on Tuesday, 22 November 2005 at 11:25am GMT