Thinking Anglicans

Brazil protests Southern Cone action

Episcopal News Service reports BRAZIL: Bishops protest Southern Cone archbishop’s unauthorized visit, violation of Windsor Report.

The bishops of the Episcopal Anglican Church of Brazil issued an open statement April 9 expressing their “strong repudiation” of a recent unauthorized visit by Southern Cone Archbishop Gregory Venables to Recife “where he took part in and celebrated at official occasions outside his Province without the knowledge and consent of the Archbishop of the Province of Brazil and this House of Bishops…”

The full text of the open statement is included there, and is reproduced here below the fold.

This is not the first complaint that Brazilian bishops have made, see for example this letter (PDF) dated October 2005 addressed directly to the Primate of the Southern Cone, and this letter (PDF) dated November 2005 addressed to the Archbishop of Canterbury.

Footnote: photos of his visit can be found here.

Letter dated 3 April 2008

The House of Bishops of the Episcopal Anglican Church of Brazil gathered in Curitiba unanimously express their strong repudiation of the recent visit by the Archbishop of the Southern Cone to the city of Recife, where he took part in and celebrated at official occasions outside his Province without the knowledge and consent of the Archbishop of the Province of Brazil and this House of Bishops.

This disrespectful and arrogant attitude against the Province of Brazil, is another element of discord caused by the Archbishop of the Province of the Southern Cone since the ecclesiastical court hearing and deposition of Robinson Cavalcanti. As it is known by all the Anglican Communion, Mr. Cavalcanti was deposed through a lawful and canonical process due to his breaking of ordination vows.

The action of the Primate of the Southern Cone represents an attack on the pillars of the Anglican tradition, which include respect to Provincial autonomy and collegiality among the Primates of the Communion. Equally, this attitude, unheard of in the Communion, clearly contradicts the Windsor Report and the resolution by the last Primates meeting in Tanzania in February 2007.

The Primate of the Southern Cone has repeatedly violated those boundaries through official acts as he invites, receives and cares pastorally for the dissident clergy, bishops, communities and dioceses from other Provinces. This is also exemplified by what has been happening recently with our sister provinces of the United States and Canada.

What at the beginning of those regrettable events of the schism in Recife was seen as a pastoral care provision for the deposed bishop and those who followed him, has become a formal primatial reception of those deposed. It has also been transformed into unacceptable acts of primatial nature within the jurisdiction of our province.

We appeal to His Grace, the Archbishop of Canterbury, and the Primates of the Anglican Communion to consider this vehement protest by the Province of Brazil in order to avoid a serious rupture with our Anglican tradition.

The consequences of such unilateral and disrespectful gesture of Archbishop Gregory Venables to a sister Province represents a serious breach of the bonds of affection and loyalty, respect and interdependence in the Anglican Communion. Let us remember that arrogance has never been, and will never be, a wise companion for relationships!

Yours ever in Christ,

++ Maurício Andrade

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
3 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
EPfizH
EPfizH
13 years ago

In response to this action, a post was made at Stand Firm. The post received a response from Bishop Iker of the Diocese of Fort Worth. He and his diocese are being cultivated for accession to Southern Cone. As follows: The action of the Primate of the Southern Cone represents an attack on the pillars of the Anglican tradition Not for the Prayer Book, the Bible, the Apostolic Succession or the Sacraments, not Christ or Councils or Communion in both kinds, not for faithfulness to Truth, not even for altar candles or expository preaching; the Episcopal Church of Brazil has… Read more »

Bill
Bill
13 years ago

Matthew 23:24 comes to mind:

“You blind guides, who strain out a gnat and swallow a camel!

Ford Elms
Ford Elms
13 years ago

“Does anyone else find this ridiculous?” Me, ma’am. What of to those conservatives who have defined the pillars of the Anglican Church to be encompassed in the exclusion of gay people, or a radically innovative approach to Scriptural authority? And, as for straining at gnats and swallowing camels, that pretty much encapsulates the Right, as far forth as I can see. I mean, they can read a verse that says revilers, slanderers and homosexuals won’t enter the Kingdom, then proceed to revile and slander anyone who disagrees with their interpretation of that verse (I know there are other verses, so… Read more »

3
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x