Thinking Anglicans

GAFCON 2 concludes with Communique and Commitment

Here is the full text of the document issued at the end of the conference in Nairobi. There is also a PDF version here.

There was an earlier press release containing the text of a resolution agreed by an unspecified number of GAFCON bishops: GAFCON votes to expand.

Much other material is available from this page. English readers may be particularly interested in the following contributions:

27
Leave a Reply

avatar
3000
27 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
23 Comment authors
CharlotteCynthiaRobert ian WilliamsPerry ButlerThe Rev'd Mervyn Noote Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of
Malcolm
Guest
Malcolm

Reading carefully the communique from Nairobi, I wonder how those who drafted it and those who voted for it can square the tone and sentiments with Jesus’s very clear teaching set out in tomorrow’s Gospel reading in Luke 18 v 9 – 14 the Pharisee and the Tax Collector. also, the fact that Jesus chose his Disciples from people on the margins and not from the religious leadership who were full of judgement of others and of their own importance.

Concerned Anglican
Guest
Concerned Anglican

Resolutions agreed, anathemas pronounced, lashings of hubris and post colonial antagonisms. A background of an exported and proxy war between conservative and liberal Americans and what seems like a very unhealthy preoccupation with sexual matters. All offered by unidentified signatories claiming to speak on the part of vast numbers of Anglicans. The truth is that these millions, however socially conservative they may be, are loyal to their Church. They are not thinking daily of the supposed iniquities of the now retired Bishop Gene Robinson and would be surprised to learn that they were ever in future to be anything other… Read more »

Jeremy
Guest
Jeremy

So the border-crossings will now increase.

Perry Butler
Guest
Perry Butler

“Many of the least believing ( clergy), male and female, are in central leadership positions in the church” Paul Perkin really? The sad thing is that most of those in Nairobi will believe Paul Perkin’s caricature………..

Father Ron Smith
Guest

I, too, was jolted by today’s Gospel reading – from Luke’s parable of the Pharisee and the publican. The jolt for me – as it probably affected those listening to Jesus who had respect for the Pharisee’s uprightness – was the sting in the tail. That Jesus commended the known sinner for his humility. He was justified by this. The Pharisee, on the other hand, was not justifed – because of his boasting about his own (undoubted) righteousness according to The Law.
Food for thought here.

sjh
Guest
sjh

What I find so fascinating about Mike Ovey’s talk is that he accuses western culture of narcissism, without any sense of how modern evangelicalism displays all the same traits of entitlement, intolerance of dissent, self-righteousness, etc.

His talk presents the classic case why his dualism is so wrong and dangerous. But he at least uncovers for us the true origins of homosexuality: pride apparently.

No wonder so many people reject this kind of religion.

robert Ian wiliams
Guest
robert Ian wiliams

Please note this in the communique:

“We recognize that we have differing views over the roles of men and women in church leadership.”

That is Gafconese for, we can’t agree what Holy Scripture says on this subject…but we can’t say that explicitly, because the Homosexuals will say that there can also be a variety of scriptural interpretation on sexuality!

Bishops Nazir Ali and Jensen actually preached on the clarity and perspicuity of scripture!

Condemnation of polygamy , but nothing on divorce ..as ACNA is riddled with it! He that pays the piper, pipes the tune!

Simon Sarmiento
Guest

Fr Ron Smith has drawn attention on his own blog to an earlier draft of this communique, and an analysis made by someone else of the differences:

http://livingtext.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/gafcon-2013-nairobi-communique-draft.html

http://livingtext.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/changes-to-gafcons-nairobi-communique.html

Fr Ron’s own comments on this (scroll down)
http://kiwianglo.wordpress.com/2013/10/27/changes-made-to-original-gafcon-communique/

Alastair Newman
Guest

Rev Paul Perkin no doubt receives his stipend from the thoroughly “heterodox” Diocese of Southwark…

Lorenzo
Guest

I actually ministered in the parish next door to P. Perkin’s for seven or eight years but have never been able to figure out whether his congregation actually goes along with all this. Can anyone tell us? I suspect the same applies to many a CofE ‘minister’ present.

cryptogram
Guest
cryptogram

I too was struck by today’s gospel hot on the heels of GAFCON. I see the parable as a straight comment on the two kinds of religion, of works and of faith. One would expect the GAFCON Fathers, evangelicals almost to a man (gender reference intended!), to note that faith is commended rather than works. But not them. It seems to me that the Gospel offers us the exact opposite of Kennedy’s much quoted inaugural address. “Ask not what you can do for God, but what God can do for you.”

commentator
Guest
commentator

Could Fr Perkin be kind enough to name these wonderfully vigorous churches, especially the LARGEST church in England?

Simon Sarmiento
Guest

Continuing my earlier comment…

Further information about the earlier draft of the communique is in this post:

http://davidould.net/?p=6135

And also in this one:

http://liturgy.co.nz/gafcon-true-anglican-communion/17080

Jane Charman
Guest
Jane Charman

Mike Ovey strikes me as a clever man whose personal preoccupations are leading him into some problematic places. I particularly objected to his appropriation of Bonhoeffer, a wise and compassionate theologian who would certainly have critiqued the kind of ‘splitting’ which is characteristic of so much of Ovey’s thinking. Ovey’s twin monoliths, the ‘holy South’ and the ‘evil West’ exist only in his imagination. All human society exhibits some positive and some problematic features, including some which call for repentance. Obscuring that helps no-one. Ovey is most deeply ambivalent when he speaks about human rights and social justice issues which… Read more »

Doug18
Guest
Doug18

Here in the U.S. many evangelical Christians start foaming at the mouth when it comes to homosexuality but suddenly hit the mute button on the issue of divorce. The participants of GAFCON have done the same thing. It only serves to prove that their movement is based largely on an intense dislike of homosexuality. A religious movement based on hate can’t go far.

John Waldsax
Guest
John Waldsax

Jane Your post is proof of how different people can read the same text and draw different, even opposing conclusions from it. Your comment particularly puzzles those of us who have stood in the Ploetzenzee hut where Bonhoeffer’s colleagues were hung on piano wire. It amazes those in my family who objected on moral and political principles to the policies of the Nazis. It shocks us who experienced the 1930’s struggle over religious authority with the state and lived in the bombed 1945 ruins of, of all places, Wuppertal-Barmen. To us Bohoeffer was exactly as Mike Ovey related, the advocate… Read more »

Ron Caldwell
Guest
Ron Caldwell

GAFCON accomplished two things: 1-rallied the troops against rights for homosexual persons, and 2-created a separate Anglican Communion structure for conservatives. This is a struggle between the Anglican Global South, aided by their First World homophobic allies, and the Anglican Global North. The South is fighting against the tide of history and modernity. It will eventually lose but it can create havoc in the meantime. More at my blog: Episcopalschismsc.blogspot.com

Richard Ashby
Guest
Richard Ashby

So Gafcon is happy to live with differences about women priests but not about same sex relationships. I thought they wanted us to believe the same thing everywhere and always as they do?

Jane Charman
Guest
Jane Charman

John, I hope you have misunderstood me. Dietrich Bonhoeffer is a theologian I greatly admire and The Cost of Discipleship is a book that means a great deal to me. The Nazis who persecuted the Confessing Church and murdered Bonhoeffer also persecuted and murdered many homosexuals. I say they were wrong on both counts. What do you say?

Savi Hensman
Guest
Savi Hensman

The reference to Bonhoeffer is rather strange. Many Christians holding views on homosexuality not dissimilar to some GAFCON leaders colluded with the Nazis to herd gays and lesbians into concentration camps, along with others they considered unrighteous. Today, these leaders collude with hate-mongering politicians to damage the lives of some and poison the hearts of others with hatred or callous indifference. This is surely worldliness of the worst kind. Interestingly his attack on human rights includes the use of the term ‘pro-­same-­sex policies’ to try to rubbish calls for decriminalisation.

AndrewT
Guest
AndrewT

John Waldsax, is comparing same-sex love to a genocidal, racist regime really a wise move? It is not enough for Christians to be countercultural. They need to be able to explain exactly what they are countering and why. In the recent debate over same-sex marriage, conservative Christians lost the debate because there was no cogent moral justification for their arguments.

The Rev'd Mervyn Noote
Guest

This is an empty shell of a communique (but then communiques usually are). Not surprising, when as others have noted, all that unites GAFCON, is a common hatred of gays. On all other substantive theological dividing issues within Anglicanism, including gender and sex-as-far-as-it-relates-to-straights, GAFCON’s supporters are all over the place. The document says nothing of substance, and promises no actions of substance. Basically, they got a big conference together to prove they weren’t irrelevant because everyone had basically forgotten about them. How relevant is GAFCON? They got Canterbury to go on a 9,000 mile detour and preach a really stupid… Read more »

Perry Butler
Guest
Perry Butler

Is there a list of the Gafcon bishops anywhere?

Robert ian Williams
Guest
Robert ian Williams

No list Perry, because a third of them have never been Anglican!

Cynthia
Guest
Cynthia

“The silence of its Western members speaks volumes.”

Yes. It most certainly does. Thank you for speaking up. This LGBT person is tired and up to her eyes in work.

Charlotte
Guest
Charlotte

Having experienced, very unwillingly, the militarist and nationalistic liturgies of the American churches who follow the GAFCON line, and in particular their custom, during the Iraq War, of parading American flags up to the altar at each service while singing “God Bless America” — well, then, I have to think that Dietrich Bonhoeffer would have preached against those who now call themselves “Confessing Anglicans” every bit as strongly as he preached against those who, in his own time, cooperated with the nationalistic, militaristic travesty of Lutheranism sponsored by the Nazi regime. I do have to agree that the appropriation of… Read more »