Helen King sharedconversations Surviving General Synod 2021-2026: ‘calming our lurking fear’
Michelle Burns Guarding the Flock A Seat at the Table, Provided You Know Your Place
Hatty Calbus Surviving Church How Untreated Boarding School Survivors Have Run and Harmed the Church
I have always thought that, with certain relatively rare exceptions, the Church of England is a middle-class or upper-class organisation.
Is that apparent state by choice or accident? And if the latter, why?
One historical reason for this is that traditionally most ordinands studied at Oxford or Cambridge and most entrants to those Universities had been at public schools (in the English sense). Many colleges were patrons of well-paid livings to which their graduates were appointed and which were often stepping stones to more senior posts. Both ++ William Temple and ++ Geoffrey Fisher were headmasters of public schools. More recently + George Snow (father of Jon) went directly from being headmaster of Ardingly to Bishop of Whitby. I think remnants of this tradition still remain. My father came from a poor background… Read more »
“I firmly believe that these attitudes persist both at Oxbridge and in the CofE”. Anecdotal evidence: I was at Oxford nearly half a century ago. In my personal opinion, among students such attitudes were confined to just a few people and a couple of colleges. They may have been more widespread among the older generation, and perhaps those who stayed in the system were more exposed to it, but it was pretty absent in my everyday student life. I don’t think it was because I went around with my eyes closed! Mind you, some of those “few people” at “a… Read more »
I never met any of these ‘typical public school’ people at Cambridge, or else stayed well away from them, even though I had attended a publc school. My friends were all grammar or comprehensive school boys (there weren’t any girls).
I am talking about 1972-75.
I was just a few years later, 1977-80, and there were women (shock, horror, but the skies didn’t fall! And it did make college more interesting). I definitely did know a few people who had been at “significant” public schools, and some of them veered towards the attitudes that we are talking about. Perhaps they were more common among those doing Greats (i.e. classics) or PPE, rather than among the scientists, mathematicians and engineers that I mingled with. Or perhaps the college was achieving some success in its attempts to broaden the social profile of the student body (and it… Read more »
The class thing has been going on for centuries, though. I always find it infuriating that some think John is unlikely to have written the gospel because ‘he was a fisherman’.
Exactly why someone should be thought incapable of writing very thoughtfully in Greek when aged 80, just because at 20 he perhaps only spoke Aramaic and fished to earn a living, is beyond me.
John had another 60 years to learn Greek, and had been taught theology by Son of God – but he couldn’t possibly write anything any good … because his first job was fishing …
The idea that the disciples only spoke Aramaic is probably incorrect. Greek was the lingua franca in the Levant, and it is reasonably likely that Our Lord spoke Greek in a lot of his public ministry. The few occasions when he used Aramaic – ‘epphatha’, ‘talitha cumi’, ‘eli lama sabachthani’ are noted for that reason.
Thanks Matthew, very helpful. It makes it even more the case that people are basically saying ‘this guy was a fisherman when he was 20, so he can’t have been clever enough to come up with world-leading insights’.
Which is missing that he might have been plenty clever enough, but that educational opportunities in first century Capernaum were not like those in Jerusalem or Athens.
Do the ‘world leading’ insights that constitute the Gospel require cleverness for their understanding or articulation?
Apparently so, according to many 19th/20th century university theologians. Someone from the Capernaum can’t possibly have had the insight John had. It would have taken a person with training more like theirs to see things that clearly.
After 2000 years we still have a ‘Can anything good come from Nazareth?’ mindset. Nathanael left his tree to find out, but do we?
Rerum Novarum, I agree. We somehow want to view Jesus and his followers as working class and uneducated, matching our picture of rural Galilee. But is that correct? There may have been rural villages, but they were placed amongst well connected Hellenistic cities. Not just Sepphoris and Tiberias but the Decapolis cities. Gadara, just SE of the Sea of Galilee, produced poets and philosophers such as Menippus (3rd Cent BCE), Meleager (1st Cent BCE) Philodemus (1st Cent BCE) and Theodorus (1st Cent CE). Gadara had a brain drain problem, they all moved away eventually, but it shows that people born… Read more »
Cheers Simon. As Anglicans we may not be fully on board with Marian apparitions, but look who Mary appears to – often peasants, the young, humble and marginalised. There is a pattern. Alongside your very good point that rural Galilee was connected with the wider world, there is the consideration that a simple rural life provides space and depth to develop wisdom. I caught a very good Youtube video last week considering what Jesus did between 12 and 30. It made the point that the information is largely, if briefly, in the gospels. He grew up, learned his father’s trade,… Read more »
But what was his fathers trade?
“Tektwn” could mean carpenter, or it could mean stone mason, or even architect, so did he work in a simple carpenter’s workshop in Nazareth, or on the major building and commercial sites in Sephoris during Antipas’ reshaping, giving him a much different experience.
Personally I don’t buy into Jesus being of poor peasant stock. He seemed to be able to relate well to the “lower” classes, I don’t dispute that, but he was well educated, and competent teaching and relating to wealthy landowners such as Mary Magdalen, Mary and Martha, and Joseph of Arimethea.
Right, and Sephoris was 4 km from Nazareth, making it likely he would have spent time working there. One factor is our difficulty in grasping how Jesus’ human and divine natures came together: what must learning the scriptures in the synagogue have been like for their ultimate author? Another is that being born into the peasantry doesn’t limit a person’s innate abilities. There have been great peasant scientists: Laplace, Gregor Mendel and Santiago Ramon y Cajal for example. Caucher Birkar, who was born in 1978 and grew up in a peasant family near the Iran-Iraq border has won the Fields… Read more »
When did Joseph die? We assume he died early, but there’s nothing about it.
As the boss’s son he was in a position to leave the hired men to get on with the work, while he and his brother followed Jesus.
The quotations in Aramaic do not necessarily imply that Aramaic was only spoken in those cases. When Jesus said my God my God why hast thou forsaken me, the crowd thought he was invoking Elijah. This is plain daft. Why on Earth should they imagine he was calling Elijah? Only by quoting the exact words used, in Aramaic, does it make any sense. Eli eli meaning my God my God bears a very plausible resemblance to a call on Elijah. Only by quoting the Aramaic can the misunderstanding of the crowd be understood. In the other cases the Aramaic words… Read more »
They are so noted in a Greek language NT on the understanding that eventual readers may not/do not know the semitic language.
You have the matter upside down.
Thank you for this elucidation, Christopher. Can you recommend some books on the subject? Don’t forget to provide the ISBN numbers, mind.
See the comment from William above. You don’t need an ISBN link for something fairly obvious.
For a semi-scholarly account, something like Did Jesus Speak Greek? by Scott Greaves explores this area, and his dissatisfaction with the “Aramaic Hypothesis”. The author is an academic, but this is a more readable account. It’s 2015, so beginning to be a little dated perhaps.
With politician Denis Healey, a Biblical critic looking strictly at his grandfather (a poor tailor from rural Ireland) and his childhood home (a modest, working-class town in post-WWI Yorkshire) and applying the same logic as to the apostles, would declare it highly implausible that he could seamlessly pivot between different languages. Yet, as BBC journalists documented, Healey was a brilliant polyglot who could speak fluent, idiomatic, well-accented French, German, and Italian off-the-cuff, even handling highly technical military and economic terminology seamlessly.
Hmmm. Then why was the centurion surprised that Paul spoke Greek? I bet it wasn’t that common in rural Palestine. But this is only opinion. I am not a theologian.
The assumption here is that John of the Twelve is the author of the 4th Gospel. That has been contested.
That said, I agree with the drift of your comments.
But today most ordinands train on regional courses. Even amongst those in colleges, few go to Oxbridge ones. I admit the attitude lingers, but the numbers do not. However… a few years ago I was in a meeting of senior TEI staff looking at the beginnings of what is now Common Awards. The Head of the Ministry Division told us that in the new dispensation, the C of E would still pay for some ordinands to do degrees at Oxford and Cambridge because otherwise where would all the future Deans and bishops (and TEI staff) come from? I was sitting… Read more »
I trained to be an ABM (as I think it then was) selector in 2000, when Margaret Sentamu was in charge of selector training, and of our residential group. It wasn’t Oxbridge or public school, but it was definitely not for the working classes. And that seemed to be deliberate. I challenged it a couple of times which didn’t go down particularly well. And there was an occasion when I was at Wycliffe (mid-80s) when there was a discussion of the working classes as if they were analysing interesting zoological specimens. Certainly from an alien culture. I think because of… Read more »
As someone from humble origins once I’d been to Durham and Cambridge I found myself in this quixotic position where I knew how to be middle class but would never quite make the grade for the reasons I’ve outlined in this thread. Back home when I read the lesson at a funeral for example my contemporaries say I talk all posh. However, you know who you really are when the archdeacon says “what did your father do?” At first I was embarrassed as I explained that he was a steelworker, which was of course the archdeacon’s intention, a few years… Read more »
Why didn’t you use steelworker’s stout language to tell him to eff off? We are too polite in England.
If someone asked me that I think I might answer “He helped to kill Germans, thereby freeing the world from fascism”
Historically, ordination was one of the very few professions thought suitable for younger sons of aristocratic families and for sons of the gentry. It was a gentlemen’s profession. Such clergy often acquired livings – sometimes multiple livings- from their families or Oxbridge colleges who had the patronage. You can see this in novels by eg Jane Austen and Anthony Trollope. Some remnants of this system exist; when I was an ordinand at Oxford I met an ordinand at another college who would be going to a curacy in one of his family’s parishes. And I have been to induction services… Read more »
I don’t think that controversial. Establishment brings this in its wake, invariably. The real question is, to my mind, how to let the Church of England find a new mission face, untethered from the parts of its past that don’t contribute to this. I am unsure even if desired, it would know how to do this, or would dare to ask how to do it. I would never be accused of being a Whig historian; I believe deeply in the heritage of the past and the communion of saints (especially today, and against certain Edwardian iconoclasm). Could a great leader… Read more »
Michelle Burns’ article is absolutely on point. As I read it, my mind immediately jumped to a certain Bishop who is a past master at opportunism, and whilst the beneficiary of an Oxbridge education, as demonstrated by the ‘cut glass’ accent and penchant for exhibitions at the V and A whilst in London, has actively curated their image as a great champion of the poor and fan of estates culture. There’s no doubt said Bishop has said some good things about poverty and opportunities that might not have otherwise been heard with as much prominence, if you are into early… Read more »
name and shame please!
I was so naive when I went to Westcott House, I had no idea as to how snooty the CofE was. It hadn’t really occurred to me that followers of Jesus of Nazareth would set so much store on what my Dad did for a living and where I’d been educated during my school years. The disconnect between what I read in the Gospel and the way I was treated was stark. That it was so absurd made it even harder to understand. Those who’d been to the most minor of minor public schools were held in higher esteem than… Read more »
Fr Dean , It is always cheering that you still speak warmly of your years in ministry, despite the snootiness of the COf E. It remains unreformedly snooty in the upper echelons- poor Michelle Burns suffers the treble handicap of being female, working class AND northern. Did anyone else watch Agatha Christie’s ‘Body in the Library’ on TV last night ? Because that is where those running the COf E seem stuck…. The episode screened the Saturday before illustrated that it was a Sunday morning by showing families with multiple smart children streaming off to church through the sunshine. Back… Read more »
You’re very kind Susanna, I loved being a parish priest and I ministered with some saintly people though there were challenges of course along the way. A clergy colleague once invited me to Glyndebourne, three times he told me that I could pick up a dinner jacket quite cheaply in Oxfam. Twice I sweetly told him that wouldn’t be necessary as I owned a dinner jacket. The third occasion I repeated this but in rather more direct and succinct terms. There is academic snobbery of course, though I was an undergraduate at Durham, the snootiness comes into its own about… Read more »
Until I arrived at Wycliffe Hall I didn’t know anyone who owned a dinner jacket. At least, I’d never seen anyone I knew wearing one. It was soon obvious I was in a different world. One of my fellow ordinands turned up for an exam wearing formal morning dress!
I had lived not far from Glyndebourne for more than 10 years, but didn’t know anyone who actually went there.
Reply to Father Dean- Greetings from an erstwhile ‘Aidan’s Maiden’ – that is an expression which must have long disappeared into the ether since the lads were legally let into St Aidan’s College ! I hope you told your clergy friend that dinner jackets were available in Durham- and didn’t even need an import licence. I did my social work training after a couple of years out of university working. I went to Barnett House in Oxford. I would never have survived Oxford as an undergraduate! There was a heady mix of academic snobbery- as a non Oxford graduate I… Read more »
Yes, we took exams in sub fusc, but he was the only one who wore formal morning dress. There weren’t many of us women at Wycliffe, but we did have some fun with sub fusc. I remember once wearing a pencil skirt and fishnet tights, with a voluminous white blouse and black velvet ribbon tie.
In my first curacy I was still completing the Bth. degree I started at theological college.It meant having some time off from parish work to work on and complete my dissertation. My vicar was not particularly happy about that and must have whinged to the Bishop. When i next met my Bishop:one of the London area bishops with enough letters after his name to complete a crossword puzzle he said to me You don’t really need to finish your degree do you Ian, you’ll not be.going on to be doing theology in the future. Better just get on being a… Read more »
It’s no better now in some places, Ian. The Bishop I’ve written about spent a long time going around proclaiming that estates priests (they never actually used the term working class, but that’s what they meant) didn’t need academic theology, so why bother putting them through degree programmes? A good friend of mine who was a senior member of staff at a theological college, of working class origin, and who loves learning (one of those people with enough letters for a crossword!), was utterly vitriolic about this person because, as my friend saw it, the Bishop had the benefit of… Read more »
There is some good Roman Catholic thinking about this coming out of the 1968 Medellin conference in Colombia – and the “preference for the poor”. If I understand it correctly, the church criticised itself for its past tendency to objectify the poor. The poor were people the church did things to, as passive recipients of charity and goodwill. But they had no agency of their own. The church needed to change this. People with experience of living in poverty were the experts in their own condition. They need to claim their own subjectivity, and be enabled to develop their own… Read more »
Ministry in deprived areas should benefit from ‘living alongside’ and not just ‘preaching top down’; and ministry may benefit from being founded around collaborations alongside the actual projects and aspirations of the community itself. For a fantastic example of this kind of ministry (in the Gorbals) read: ‘Geoff’ by Ron Ferguson.
I think you’re right on this – top down preaching at people is of very limited value (as the late John Hull explored) in any context with people of any socio-economic status. So many people (like this Bishop) totally misunderstand the value of rigorous study, though. I’m a liberationist at heart, and for me, I have always studied to develop my ability to faithfully (and accurately) understand so I can then use those tools to help and guide others as they explore. Unsurprisingly my approach is grounded in certain educational theories that are themselves liberationist to a greater or lesser… Read more »
Another example is maybe Henry Corbett, who got a starred first in theology at Cambridge and was a Harrovian. I knew him slightly at my college.
https://efcheritagesociety.com/reverend-henry-corbett/
https://togetherforthecommongood.co.uk/uncategorised/long-term-leadership
Hidden sister, there is much in your post I will agree with, and much of valuable ministry can be done with people working alongside the aspirations of the community.
But there is still a difference between people coming into the community from outside (albeit with excellent intentions) and a programme working to ensure that members of the community can themselves become educated and ordained, and then supported pastorally, theologically and politically through the inevitable friction and opposition when they seek to put their insights into practice.
I agree, Simon, and thank you for adding that point.
Congratulations on completing the degree and having the tenacity to do so. I’m not sure things have changed much since you were serving your title.
Together for the Church of England has set the agenda. Division.
Together for the Church of England and the Alliance both have clear agendas.
Helen, keeping you in my prayers – you’ve had a difficult few months.
On another subject, a blessed All Saints’ Day to all TA readers.
Why, out of curious interest, rather than criticism, is “Bishop” frequently written with an upper case first letter when referring to the office, rather than as a title for an individual (which is, of course, then followed by said individual’s name). One may speak of popes or Pope Leo, but surely not of Popes (unless of course it is “The Pope’s”, which is a quite different thing altogether).
There’s clearly a lot of hurtful nonsense being said and heard about class. In my experience, some of the most theologically gifted clergy work or have worked in working class environments, not least as their congregations will call them out if they are using pretentious language to try and hide a lack of clarity of thought. Contrast that to the dreadful preaching I’ve heard at some cathedrals where there is little engagement with the text, and a rather stodgy self-satisfiedness. Perhaps theology is wasted on church communities where the community is more interested in the building, local rituals (this is… Read more »
What do you mean by ‘tribal’? ‘I and those who agree with me are thoughtful and informed, those others who don’t must hold their views for irrational, clannish reasons.’ It reveals rather a colonialist mindset.
My suggestion is merely that having three separate colleges in and around Oxford with histories of radically different theologies is more likely to reinforce differences than to help people see what unites them. I don’t know whether the Federation meaningfully ameliorates that in Cambridge.
Were Wycliffe, St. Stephen’s House and Cuddesdon to amalgamate on one site with one governing body, one teaching staff and one student body they could be a pioneer for demonstrating how the CofE could embody diversity and unity.
I have a lovely bridge in Brooklyn- are you interested in buying?
Michelle Burns and Hatty Calbus write about the damaging effect of the class structure in the Church of England. Helen King writes about her personal experience of life in recent months. The majority of comments are posted about class structure and related, diverse issues of abuse. The Church of England is hyperconscious of status, class, hierarchy and authority. It is part of the DNA of the Church. I’m a grammar school boy; my younger brother went to a secondary modern school; he has a degree, I don’t. I’m conscious of the education markers that identify my location in the Church… Read more »
I would have thought that, within TA at least, the complete opposite is true. TA has such conversations all the time. Whether TA is read widely or has any influence I have no idea.
Let me help you: “no” and “no”.
With the focus on surviving I am surprised that there has been no mention of the distressing case of the curate who has resigned because of alleged racist abuse. I believe her church was St Mary’s Putney.
The lack of comment may be due to the fact we still know almost nothing about the case apart from the allegation of racist abuse. We do not know what caused the blow up, or in even general terms what offensive words or phrases were used.
That is correct – I have looked it up online and there is practically nothing reported. We only have one side of the story and nothing at all to clarify. This isn’t satisfactory because serious allegations have been made.
I think we will hear more of this matter – one distressing thing after another these days. The news is only from about a week ago, I think
Sadly, I doubt that we will hear more. An article in the Church Times adds nothing. It is all the more disquieting as St Mary’s website has the following statement: “ We are an Inclusive Church, rooted in the local community. Our worship expresses the Liberal Catholic tradition. We welcome all without exception, irrespective of gender, ethnic origin, sexual orientation or church background and you are most welcome to come along and see what you make of us.”
Does any of this have any relevance to the kind of culture change that external safeguarding professionals have consistently urged – of course it does. The weight of traditions and expectations that don’t stand up to scrutiny is too great to bear. Something will break sometime. The culture says “let it not be me”, theology says “we are all broken”. I wrote something on Surviving Church a while back about psychological “splitting”, which is a form of unconscious denial which has been assimilated to the status quo. We have (collectively) no excuse for not knowing. It is incorrect to think… Read more »
I am finding some of these opinions uncomfortable – especially in Hatty’s piece. Whilst I can see what she is saying, I think the tone is wrong and misguided. So, Disclosure…. I am a boarding school survivor. I was groomed, but didn’t have any of the atrocities of the Smyth regime. I have worked through a huge amount. I have run churches and been part of key church leaderships reviews and senior leadership…. blah blah. But I am not “untreated”! I am not like some wooden fence in need of a coating of Cuprinol to make me more resilient or… Read more »
Thank you for this and for putting your finger on the key issue of leadership (and for the record, I am a northern grammar school lad) Baked into our systems is a lack of accountability at every level that inevitably leads to a lack of support. It’s quite hard to see how the current structures could morph into something that could deliver genuine accountability. At a personal level, 40+ years in, I just feel quite lonely. If the only conversation I ever have with someone in authority is an MDR every couple of years, it’s hard to feel loved or… Read more »
I would go further. Similar background to you. I was never groomed. I was never beaten. I was never abused. I am not a survivor. I don’t know any boy who was.
I was groomed and abused- not severly though, by a paedophile Anglican priest at my southern Grammar School. Don’t worry- I’m over it. I didn’t get PTSD and I gather they caught up with him in the end. I did report it a few years ago, really just for statistical reasons. He died about 7 years ago I believe.
Reading A Seat at the Table reminds me of a famous sketch…. The Clerical Class Sketch (Three figures stand side-by-side in a row. Archbishop is tall, aristocratic, wearing elaborate, immaculate vestments. Vicar is of average height, wearing a crisp, sensible cassock. Working-Class Professional/Safeguarding Advisor is shorter, wearing sharp, modern corporate-wear and holding a clipboard.) Archbishop: (Looking straight ahead, then peering down his nose) I look down on them because I have an ancient pedigree, institutional power, and a direct line to God. I am leadership. Vicar: (Looking up at the Archbishop) I look up to him because he represents the… Read more »
I wish this wasn’t true. Ufortunately I had this attitude all the time and then finding out that your daughter has gone to Cambridge……….
Posh-boy misery memoirs sell well. However, it should be made clear that they do not wish that they had gone to local state comprehensive, even they realise that bullying exists outside boarding schools, and that they would have been natural targets. Where they wanted to go was a nice private day school, just as exclusive as their boarding school. I also worry that emphasis on abuse & bullying in boarding schools ignores fact that it also goes on in state sector, particularly in our digital era where leaving the premises & going home does not curtail bullying or grooming. I… Read more »
I’m not clear why highlighting the particular issues of boarding school ‘ignores the fact that it also goes on in state sector’. Of course it does. That does not detract from the fact that there are particular psychological problems that arise in many who attend boarding schools. Psychological problem are no less real because posh boys develop them, and the fact that these posh boys often go on to top jobs in state and church means that they are very often visited on many others because of the way they exercise their ministry. That is the point of Hattie Calbus’… Read more »