Thinking Anglicans

opinion

Rose Hudson-Wilkin Christian Today What Christians get wrong about Politics

Angus Ritchie Huffington Post What Do the Bishops Know About Politics? More Than You’d Think…

Eliza Filby Church Times The Church, the ballot-box, and Mrs Thatcher

Economist Gender, violence and religion: When north and south agree

Linda Woodhead Theos What is the future for religion in Britain?

Giles Fraser The Guardian Give me hypocrites over cynics any time. At least they aspire to something

Antonia Blumberg Huffington Post Christians Celebrate Ash Wednesday Around The World [Photos From Around The World]

17
Leave a Reply

avatar
3000
17 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
15 Comment authors
Father DavidrjbJohn BunyanStephen MorganPeter Owen Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of
Pam
Guest
Pam

Thanks for photos of Lent around the world. This is a time for reflection and, for me, reading the Psalms.

Neil
Guest
Neil

Could those responsible for posting what Rose Hudson-Wilkin has written explain why they have done so? I don’t really understand fully what she is saying, nor the way in which she expresses herself – to me it is barely literate. The point seems to be that we should be concerned about the totality of people’s lives because God is. Could somebody please explain the 3rd paragraph – I have read and re-read it and can’t understand what the point is? Also in the 4th paragraph, what is a set of political ideology? This looks incredibly muddled to me, and I’m… Read more »

jill Armstead
Guest
jill Armstead

Neil, Rose Hudson-Wilkins thoughtful piece clearly springs from a warm heart – what more could you ask for? She is not a ‘revd doctor’ and frankly, all the better for it.

Feria
Guest
Feria

While services for Ash Wednesday are on topic: I spotted this morning a nuance that I haven’t noticed in liturgy before: in the BCP, the Collect for Ash Wednesday is addressed to the Trinity as a whole; whereas the Collect for Quinquagesima is addressed specifically to the Father; and the Collect for the first Sunday in Lent is addressed specifically to the Son. It got my attention initially because of the beauty of the language used to deliver these points, but it also leaves an interesting issue to explore: are there particular types of prayer that are most appropriately addressed… Read more »

Father Ron Smith
Guest

Regarding the enquiry from ‘feria’ regarding the practice of address members of the trinity separately; there are many examples around, e.g.:

“Our Father……” (at the direction of Jesus)
“Jesus Christ, Son of the Living God….”
“Come, Holy Spirit…..” in the Ordinal.

If God really is Trinity as well as One; then surely, one is not neglecting the other Persons when one addresses Father, Son, or Holy Spirit?

gareth
Guest

Jill, Neil is making a point about clarity. You don’t need to be a Revd Dr to be able to write. Rose’s piece is either terribly written or terribly edited. Either way it is a poor piece not because it is not at all clear in several places.

Savi Hensman
Guest
Savi Hensman

I suspect that Rose Hudson-Wilkin wrote it in a hurry and it was not edited with sufficient care. At the risk of sounding pedantic, I do not think copy-editing and fact-checking are always valued enough these days.

Jill Armstead
Guest
Jill Armstead

Gareth – I had no difficulty understanding it – I might not agree with her philosophy – she has been very rude about traditional Catholics for example – but I would not dream of criticising the quality and style of her writing – unkind and unnecessary in the circumstances.

Neil
Guest
Neil

Jill – could you please then explain the point in her third paragraph, and perhaps summarise what her insights are? I still don’t ‘get’ what Rose H-W is trying to say – and guess it must be something, given she is writing about what Christians get wrong about politics. She is in a unique position in her job, and I would be interested to hear what you think is being said. I’ve read the piece yet again, and looked up the OT story, but am still really none the wiser. Given how unclear and muddled the contribution appears to be,… Read more »

John
Guest
John

Jill, I agree with you. And here we have yet another situation where two people in one sense at the opposite ends of the spectrum agree on something important. And in that agreement – and disagreement – we find something essential – and admirable – about the Church of England.

Disgraceful
Guest
Disgraceful

I agree that the piece of R H-W is quite unintelligible. She may be a good person, a good priest and whatever else, but this is a piece of poorly written muddled thinking. It feels as the piece is building up to a point that is never made. Even after ignoring the poor grammar (something I find difficult to do) I can see nothing but strings of words, some of which are made into sentences.

Barry
Guest
Barry

Dorothy L. Sayers wrote that Christian work is work well done. If, as Christians, we are preparing a piece for publication, it behoves us, to the best of our ability, to see that it is clear and accurate. Perhaps, in the present discussion, we are being reminded that in our day one form of Christian asceticism may be pausing to reflect before rushing into print?

Peter Owen
Guest

To answer Neil’s question, I chose the piece by Rose Hudson-Wilkin because I thought it might be of interest to readers. It looks as if that was true for some (but not all) of you. What more can one ask for?

Stephen Morgan
Guest
Stephen Morgan

I find it difficult to ignore the rude, patronising, and downright distasteful comments made on this thread concerning the article by Rose Hudson-Wilkin.

If these people are ‘Thinking Anglicans’ then I think I’m due a period of blissful ignorance.

John Bunyan
Guest
John Bunyan

I for one found Rose Hudson-Wilkin’s article thought-provoking, warm-hearted and wise.

rjb
Guest
rjb

Having read Rose H-W’s article, I’d say that it looks like a condensed version of a fuller argument that has been hastily reduced to ‘main-points’. Sadly this kind of thing makes its way into print quite often, as intelligent and capable writers meet the implacable limitations of space. If Rose’s article flows badly and is lacking in detail we might hope that her address at the Temple Church will provide opportunity for elaboration.

Father David
Guest
Father David

“What do bishops know about politics?”
So, was Bishop Brooke Foss Westcott misguided when he broke off from his preparations to produce a new standard edition of the New Testament in Greek in order to interfere in the coal strike of 1892 bringing about reconciliation between the striking miners and the pit owners?