Updated Saturday 31 October to add some reactions to the report.
Robin Gill and John Craven of The Centre for Anglican History and Theology at the Universities of Kent and Christ Church Canterbury have published this report: Wasted Money in a Diminishing Church: A Report on the Church of England
Madeleine Davies of the Church Times has written about it here: C of E heading for ‘financial disaster’ warn two academics.
Update
Ian Paul Psephizo Is wasted money the problem with the Church of England?
Philip North Church Times Money alone will not solve C of E’s woes
Mark Clavier Well-Tempered Are We Willing to Be a Church?
Thank you for providing the link to the Gill/Craven report. I have my own views about the recommendations supplied, but I would note that when I met Prof. Gill after an evening service at Hucking (Canterbury diocese) about 15 years’ ago, I looked around at the largely empty building and asked whether – in view of his 1993 book – the ‘myth’ of the Church being empty was still really a myth. He seemed to think that it was a myth no more. At that time Hucking had a monthly service, but this has since been discontinued, and as I… Read more »
Ah, Mr Froghole! Welcome back and please don’t leave again for so long.
At the time of your visit Mr Froghole, I happened to be the Area Dean of this Deanery. Hucking was indeed a church of small congregation while that at Hollingbourne was far larger and very energised. Prof. Gill was Hon. Priest in Charge of Hollingbourne and Hucking. In Canterbury Diocese, at that time, we began to address how the Deanery functioned, the intention, even then, to devolve certain powers and decision-making to them, (akin to some degree to a Circuit in The Methodist Church) so that they would become the main drivers of mission. While the intention was earnest, and,… Read more »
Some years ago our Diocese began to develop a system of Clusters or Partnerships (largely imposed and as a matter of interest now abandoned). My Methodist colleague commented ‘It’s just like the Circuit system. It doesn’t work and this plan won’t work. It’s typical Anglican arrogance. Did you talk to us to see what the pitfalls are?’.
Did you?
I have only skim-read the thesis of Gill and Craven – although having been a enthusiastic advocate of Robin Gill – I can see some his arguments in the late 90s early 2000s coming home to roost. My fundamental issue is the thorny problem of the deanery being the main model of decision making, strategic development, deployment etc. The theory is great, but the reality is flawed. Why? – because most deaneries don’t have the quality of strategic leadership to make those decisions. Most are moribund collections of the lay and ordained pooling to bemoan local issues, and don’t have… Read more »
As a former deanery lay chair for many years I completely agree with your analysis and comments
I must confess that I haven’t read this report but one of the things that I found so irksome about the CofE’s top heaviness was the busybody activities of all these senior clerics. Most galling of all were bishops giving general advice on how to run a parish who’d never themselves sunk so low! Most of them would push their latest ‘initiative’ with Panglossian fervour. I felt that I was having to build greater defences against the drive to infantilise me. However I fear that the turkeys will not vote for Christmas. They like having the status of five or… Read more »
I stayed 28 years in my inner urban parish which I loved. My Diocesan (whose mould I definitely did not fit) said. ‘I don’t know how you’ve stuck it Down There’.
‘Nuff said.
I’ve just lost most of what was supposed to be a day off reading Gill/Craven. It’s unusually well-written for a church report, and I rather enjoyed it. On the whole, the key recommendations reflect the kind of thing that many of our key lay leaders say – the need for a cull of senior leaders and diocesan staff (humanely, of course!) frequently comes up – but, like Tu es Petrus, I wonder about the deanery as the unit responsible for deploying clergy: I have never encountered a deanery synod up to such a task.
I do remember with something of a shudder many seemingly endless discussions in the deanery I served in in the Great Diocese of Manchester (as Nigel McCulloch was known affectionally to call it) when we were asked to formulate our plans for the missional reorganisation of our parishes.The diocesan guidelines for these discussions changed every year or two and so the discussions went on as the goal-posts shifted.I do recall one interminable meeting when, after almost two hours someone pointed out that so far nobody had mentioned God. None of our suggestions was ever acted on. Eventually, the initiative now… Read more »
Deck chairs? Titanic?
The Manchester scheme was then copied in every detail by Birmingham. It now seems that it is quietly being abandoned.
I think one of the key statements is this: In the 21st century dioceses in the Church of England almost doubled their number of administrators (including some 220 on safeguarding alone), while the number of parish clergy almost halved, and churchgoing continued to decline. But the same trend can be seen in the public sector, with the growth of administrative roles compared to front-line staff: Economists and public policy experts point to several systemic drivers that mimic the trends seen in the Church of England. (1) Modern governments face immense regulatory, legal, and risk-management pressures. Just as the Church added… Read more »
The inner logic of the godless secular state is to attract to itself responsibility for everything. Health, education, safety, offence-prevention, justice, even, mirabile dictu, the climate.
This entails an ever-burgeoning regime of law, compliance, regulation and taxation.
Responsibility to comply with the State’s requirements necessitates more and more activity, and staff to do it, in bodies like the church. So more money gets consumed doing so, at diocesan level, and more volunteers get demoralised doing so in the parishes. All of this has the gradual effect of emaciating non-State actors in society, reinforcing the hegemony of the government.
T.S. Elliot was right, liberalism drowns in a sea of regulation to solve problems they themselves create.
Where can I acquire this bumper book of useful sayings of TS Eliot that you keep quoting from?
T.S. Eliot never said or wrote this exact quote. The statement is a modern paraphrase and interpretation of Eliot’s political philosophy, accurate but not a quotation.
A paraphrase. The nearest original is:
“Liberalism can prepare the way for that which is its own negation: the artificial, mechanised or brutalised control which is a desperate remedy for its chaos.”
T.S. Eliot wrote these reflections in his 1939 book-length essay, The Idea of a Christian Society
Conservatives have no need of regulation and control, of course.
‘Yet the basic fact remains: every regulation represents a restriction of liberty, every regulation has a cost.’ Margaret Thatcher
She believed in applying regulations and restrictions to trade unions. It was capitalists and the wealthy and powerful she wanted free from regulation.
Exactly.
In terms of the Kingdom of God and the fulfilment of all things, unity and freedom can only be found under Jesus as Lord of all. Social conservatives rely on the strength of family life and, for Christians, the church as the family of God, to sustain society submitting one to another out of love and mutual respect under the authority of scripture as the word of God. Liberals however seeks to build society by passing laws and regulations not all of which support family life, and so have to pass more laws and regulations to fix the problems they… Read more »
Our Lord didn’t have much time for ‘family life’ though, did he? In fact the evidence we have suggests that he was quite opposed to it.
There is really not much evidence, per se, in one direction or the other?
Guy Carpenter, recently charged for poaching after removing a roadkill deer, saving the Council (Chargepayers) £310, by a police force which complains of underfunding and presides over a litany of unsolved crimes: ‘For historical context, just over a hundred years ago the British state spent 5% of GDP each year. Today it is closer to 50% – and we have an economically, culturally, physically and psychologically collapsing country to show for it. Just walk around any city or large town and call me a liar. Unchecked, the state will continue to increase its size and the amount of resources it… Read more »
You are so right. The Church was doing a great job of covering-up/ignoring the actions of paedophile priests etc., until the Godless Press & Godless State Police started to interfere. Theocracy is so much better.
Of course, the police, media, and the agencies of government have never perpetrated or covered up any thing egregious.
Never said that they were perfect – they are far from it. But in godless secular state such things come out due to competing agencies, and people get punished. Peter Ball & his pals even retained indelible character of priests after being convicted (loss of PTO does not prevent wearing collar & using title). On that note worth reminder how hard CoE hierarchy like saintly Eric Kemp worked to protect Bishop Peter Ball & discredit his victims.
Thank you for saying this. I’ve long contended that the CofE centralises things it shouldn’t and doesn’t centralise things it should!
Couldn’t agree more; there are so many areas where dioceses do things very differently, invoking ‘context’, but little discussion of why it’s *those* things not others.
I do like that! What about a Bishop’s prayer:
I confess to Almighty God, to the General Synod, and to you, my heavily managed brothers and sisters, that I have greatly misallocated resources.
In my thoughts and in my circular emails, I have centralised things the church should not and failed to centralise things it should.
Through my fault, through my policy update, through my most grievous top-heavy restructuring.
Therefore, I ask blessed Administrative Clarity, the holy Council of Diocesan Advisers, and you, the overworked clergy, to pray for me to the Lord of Less Paperwork.
One day the penny will drop that there are not enough priests or curates or ordinands in training to save the parish system. The lights are flashing red on the dash board and have been for some time.
Madam Sorostris, the famous clairvoyant!
Perhaps it is worth looking at the current training of priests.
Is it thorough enough?
In this Report there was mention made ecumenically about the Roman Catholic Church, The Methodist Churches, and other Free Churches, what was absent from mention and certainly should not be ignored even now in the present Religious context of Britain is the the growth of Eastern Orthodoxy in Britain, spread across different Orthodox jurisdictions, like the Greek Orthodox Church, The Russian Orthodox Church, The Serbian Orthodox Church, the Antiochian Orthodox Church and the recently established Romanian Archdiocese of Great Britain. Orthodoxy is certainly on the increase in Britain, new parishes and Monasteries are being established. There are a lot of… Read more »
Jonathan is quite right. In the last thirty years new Orthodox parishes have sprung up the length and breadth of Great Britain. The interesting thing is that so many of our young men have sought them out, changed their lives and started on the spiritual path, often with their families.
I don’t see a huge amount of evidence for this here in the second city.
By ‘second city’ do you mean Birmingham or some other place?
There are seven Orthodox churches in and around the West Midlands including the Birmingham Orthodox Cathedral, the Orthodox Cathedral of the Dormition of the Theotokos and St Andreas at Sandpits Birmingham, and St Mary and Archangel Michael, Coptic Cathedral, Caldwell Grove Solihull.
If you mean Manchester as being the ‘second city’ there are five orthodox churches.
There are five in the vicinity of Liverpool. Although Liverpool’s Alderman Savidge, when asked whether he thought Liverpool was the second city, replied indignantly that he did not. That is an honour, he said, that belongs to London.
But as regards Birmingham in particular, but also England in general, the elephant in the room is surely the phenomenal growth in Islam.
I am aware of the Orthodox churches in Birmingham – including the Tigrayan Orthodox Church which uses our building – but I am not aware of people joining from outside the ethnic groups they serve.
I understand that the Serbian Orthodox Church in Bourneville is gaining new adherents from beyond the Serbian community, particularly younger British men.
Young white men?
I believe so. I don’t know how many. Someone connected to that church observed to me that they are gaining British young men whilst losing the younger generations of Serbs.
These young men are mostly right wing culture war embraces, aka Orthobros. I should as I was a female version. The bottom will fall out in a few years as they realise the EO has no real plan to help them and the safeguarding is basically non existent and ineffectual.
To be fair, the vast majority of Orthodox in the UK still are first or second generation immigrants.
As for Greek Orthodoxy in Greece itself, whilst most Greeks still identify as Orthodox, actual church going in many part of the country is very low – and far lower than when I lived in Athens back in the 70s
Plus now Romanians and Ukrainians.I am sure some British people are attracted to Orthodoxy ( there have always been converts ) but I doubt whether the numbers are huge..
The EO is being over taken by right wing extremism and has basically no safe guarding
This is not entirely True, see the Safeguarding policy of the Archdiocese of Thyateira and Great Britain signed by His Eminence Archbishop Nikitas and see on the website the Safeguarding Policy of the Antiochian Orthodox Church Jonathan
The Gill and Craven report identifies some significant problems in Church structures. Any move towards localism would benefit in learning from the Church in Wales’ experience following the Harries Review. My observations in retirement are just a worm’s eye view of one Welsh diocese, rather than a bird’s eye view of the Province. But it seems to me that cherry picking of the Review’s recommendations led to the opposite of localism. Deaneries were reshaped, sometimes clumsily, and renamed mission or ministry areas. They were built up while old parishes were dissolved. The perception was that the new areas received new… Read more »
”I saw no meaningful devolution from a Diocesan level”. Far from it. In the Church in Wales all power is now centralised at diocesan level. Wales has put all its eggs into one basket and even to suggest that the generally loathed Local Ministry Areas are a disaster is to say that the emperor has no clothes. Everybody says it in the local churches, nobody must say it in the hearing of an archdeacon or a bishop. The imposition of Local Ministry Areas reminds me in some ways of the imposition of collective farming in Communist countries. But thanks to… Read more »
The whole country is heading for financial disaster, household by household, organisation by organisation and the country as a whole. The Church of England is not unique
There is much in this report that is important, but I am worried about the detail. The following caught my eye when discussing the potential use of the Project Spire money: ‘To save yet another increase in administrators, we hope that grants will be channeled through CMS, USPG and Christian Aid on, say, scholarships for young people from Central Africa and the Caribbean to study in the UK.’ Christian Aid just does not do that kind of thing. Historically, USPG and CMS had such programmes but they were very costly and very hit and miss. Educating people in the UK… Read more »
I agree Phil. I felt the same when I read in the CT article -“Asked whether the model would increase bureaucracy and whether deaneries had the required expertise and administrative capacity, Canon Gill said that each one would need “some admin support, either provided by competent volunteers or paid for — and more deprived deaneries should be supported centrally to do this.” The sheer vague hopefulness of statements like ‘some admin support’ would need to provided by ‘competent volunteers’ or paid for really sounds seriously out of touch with local church life and the challenges they are facing. I remain… Read more »
Thank you so much for all of your comments. I am delighted to see that our report is generating discussion on the Church of England. Our report is in two sections. The first is a Timeline of how we have come to the present dire position on finance and attendances. So far I have not noticed anyone challenging us on that. For us that is vital, because it sets out the context for any serious suggested changes that are needed. In the second part we set out our suggestions, recognising that these are just our suggestions and we hope that… Read more »
Thank you, Robin. I was a Deanery Lay chair for many years until the last triennium when I decided that younger blood needed to replace me. There is such ambivalence about deaneries. In ‘For the Church’ Martin Percy paints what is for me an over-idealised picture. My experience is that Deaneries work if they are focussed on a large centre of population and are contiguous with it – as are some in my diocese, one example is Luton. The church can speak with one voice to secular organistions and so have influence. The problem arises with deaneries which are just… Read more »
There is indeed an ambivalence about deaneries. People in the pews understand parish and they have a notion of what the diocese is, but the deanery generally leaves people perplexed. Some dioceses like the idea of delegating things to deaneries because they’re more ‘local’, but rarely delegate any actual authority to make decisions, especially where appointments or funds are concerned. And I recall there being a report to General Synod some years ago that advocated the abolition of deaneries, but I suspect that, like so many reports, that got drop-kicked into the nearest long grass. But with ever greater benefices,… Read more »
The primary legal role of the deanery synod is that its members are the electorate for the diocesan synod and the General Synod. That rather requires that its members know each other at least a little, so the synod needs to meet from time to time. One alternative would be direct election of lay representatives to diocesan synod and General Synod by all those on parish electoral rolls, but I suspect that would result in even less well-informed voters and a considerably lower turn-out.
Wigan is already one.
“With extensive building of churches and chapels in new urban areas, and enlargements even in rural areas, churchgoing reached a high point in early Victorian England.” I would query that. I’ve been watching “Churches: How to Read Them” which was a six-part BBC Four series presented by author and lawyer Richard Taylor based on his book How to Read a Church. As architectural historian William Whyte notes, the Victorians shifted away from the older Georgian view that a church was merely a room for listening to a Sunday sermon. Instead, they believed that church buildings themselves possessed evangelical power. They… Read more »
There is evidence I think not simply of denominational rivalry in building churches in the second half of the 19c but also inter- Church of England rivalry: an anglo-catholic church built to rival an evangelical one and vice versa.
How many 19th century churches were built as ‘anglo catholic’ or ‘evangelical’ churches? Very few I should have thought.
I am not very knowledgeable about these things but when I was a young anglocatholic (perhaps with my Blagden Gamlen guide book) I would tend to look in the solidly working class areas of a city to find the AC church. I am not sure they were necessarily fishing in the same ponds as the evangelicals,but Fr Butler should be able to put me right.
It is part of that great mythology, perpetuated over sherry at Pusey House, that anglo catholicism flourished in working class areas of cities. It was just as likely to take root in leafy suburbs (Solihull, Sutton Coldfield) and in market towns (Tewkesbury). There are few churches that started out as Anglo catholic from the moment the doors first opened.
Well yes, but the ones that did start off AC , a good many were in working class areas:
As far as London is concerned Bill Jacob’s book on religion in London in the 19c should help but it is a fearsome price and I haven’t seen it, though I heard his recent lecture to the Anglo-Catholic History Society. Pusey in Leeds ? Frs Lowder and Mackonochie et al?.Portsea? Yes leafy suburbs like St John’s Upper Norwood. I think more significant were post WW1 developments, led by the Congress Movement ( see W.S.Pickering, John Gunton’s books)
Yet look at where most of the great names of of the interwar Anglocatholic heyday served:
Conrad Noel: Essex market town
Bernard Walke: Cornish village
Maurice Child: Middlesex village
Alban Baverstock: Dorset village
Alfred Hope Patten: Norfolk village
Fancy giving a lecture to the Anglo-Catholic History Society ? Or something for the Newsletter? 😀
True. But along side that set the numbers of London clergy in the four chapters of Friends in Council. It was in the original chapter that the idea of the Congresses was conceived.
Blagden Gamlen himself was of course a country vicar on the Isle of Sheppey.
He was before that at St Bartholomews Derby, which along with St Lukes were in the most working class parts of Derby. Take a look at the now non existent Diocese of Wakefield and see where most of the AC churches are. As a callow youth, who should have had better things to do with my time, I worked out that if you caught a bus in Wakefield bus station you could get as far as Huddersfield before you passed through a parish that didn’t have six candles on the altar. And that doesn’t include Barnsley!
At Eastchurch where he is buried with his two wives on either side. The interesting thing about BG was his extreme right wing politics and support for the National Front. That is a side of Anglo-Catholicism that deserves further exploration. A test case is the Spanish Civil War which split anglo- Catholics, Fr “Bill”Iredell on the Republican side ( with the “Red” Dean ) and the “Annunciation Group” strongly pro Franco. Quite a bit of documentation for anyone looking for a 20c Church History PhD topic.
⁶ i went on a weekend pilgrimage to Walsingham as a student led by BG. It was weird in some ways and we all knew he was as mad as a box of frogs. Yes, he was National Front. I’ve never met any other priests who were that way inclined. It is worth saying that the London slum priests were members of Stuart Headlam’s Guild of St Matthew, arguably the first Socialist Society.
This is very much the argument Robin Gill himself made in “The Myth of the Empty Church”.
St Ouen’s Methodist Church on Route de Trodez in Jersey provides a perfect, living example of this exact building crisis mentioned in my last comment and architectural regression to solve it. What makes this case fascinating is that it represents the architectural arms race in reverse. The small chapel alongside the larger building that the congregation uses is actually the original 1809 chapel, which is the oldest purpose-built Methodist chapel on the island. It is a simple, two-story granite box built to human scale. In 1871, at the absolute height of the Victorian religious boom and denominational competition, the local… Read more »
Another view of the report here:
Is wasted money the problem with the Church of England?
https://www.psephizo.com/life-ministry/is-wasted-money-the-problem-with-the-church-of-england/
I think the main problem is that the report’s starting point is managerial rather than ecclesiological, asking, “What size should dioceses be?” Instead of, “What is a bishop.” Hence the answer, larger dioceses – far from addressing concerns that diocesan bishops have become CEOs – is only going to make this unhappy situation worse. What became of the bishop’s ordination charge to be a focus of communion, to know and be known?
Allan, I totally agree. My diocese of Edmonton has forty-six parishes, our bishop is a familiar figure in the churches of the diocese, and it’s not hard to get an appointment to see him.
Tim, I fear we’re swimming against the tide on this. Although Simon Cade has posted, referencing the primary metaphor of the Ordinal: “You cannot be a shepherd by Zoom.” The Ordinal locates episcopal ministry in the eucharistic community, not above it; hence their ministry must be relational and sacramental before it is administrative. My diocese, Bristol, is currently interviewing for a new diocesan, and I don’t want him or her to be an isolated CEO, but first and foremost one of the baptized – and I pray that he or she feels and acts this way too.
I do think Ian Paul’s assertion that: ‘The whole argument rests on a causal claim. Diocesan administration has grown, parishes have been starved of resources, and decline has followed.’ is a straw man. Perhaps I missed something, but I didn’t see that thesis in the Gill / Craven report, much less it being ‘the whole argument’ of the piece. If it was the whole argument, it would be a much shorter report. There is certainly an argument that resources are moving increasingly away from parish ministry to diocesan admin and projects, but nothing as explicit- or as easily rebutted- as… Read more »
Thank you for this very perceptive critique.
A casual read might come that conclusion, but I think statistically Ian Paul’s solutions do stand up to scrutiny. However these solutions do not address the clergy recruitment and training problem.
The statistics presented are reasonable enough but don’t support the conclusions Ian Paul makes, never mind his ‘solutions’. All first year science undergraduates are aware that correlation does not equal causation. Less well known, but just as important, lack of correlation does not equal lack of causation.
Always search for confounding factors. Increased ice cream sales are correlated with increased sun block sales. The confounding factor is the sun.
Increased ice cream sales are correlated with increased deaths by drowning too. Ice cream reduces buoyancy.
Not many people know this, but when regressing, you add more variables to a model where they correlate with the remaining error in the existing model, not with the variable being regressed. As you add regressors, the cofficients of existing terms change.
I have seen many times people say – let’s investigate all the variables which correlate to the target, and add the top 5 into the model.
This is nonsense.
An interesting response to Ian Paul’s response in which you state the following: “Are there parish clergy who are not concerned with growth?” However Ian Paul actually wrote the following: “Protect and increase parish clergy who are intentional about growth.” Being intentional about growth is quite different from being concerned about growth. I might be concerned about a leaking roof but to solve the problem I need to be intentional, i.e. do something about it. We can all agree that it is God that gives the growth (1 Cor 3.6) but planting and watering also took place. I would not… Read more »
There is a lot that I want to agree with in the report but there are some fundamental flaws; firstly they link the growth in DBF teams to the decline in congregations, their own data doesn’t show that link, some of the DBF teams that grew most quickly saw less decline and vice versa. Secondly they ignore key data, for instance in the last 60 years the number of PCCs and number of parish churches has hardly changed while the size of their worshipping community has, there is a popular case (which I disagree with but needs to be faced)… Read more »
Power.
What is it for ?
Priests have power. Bishops have even more power.
Is this power fuel to develop a career in the Church or is it the capacity to strengthen the faith and confidence of ordinary people in the pew ?
If you are not willing to give your power unconditionally to vulnerable human beings in need of love and support then you are in the wrong job.
I am keen to make a contribution to this ‘debate’ before the thread loses interest in favour of concerns arising from the General Synod elections and papers prepared for ‘consideration’ at its first meeting. I am keen because this is an important matter, though maybe/ not the major issue. I note that the thread has attracted 74 contributions to date. Good to see you Froghole. As a former fellow ‘academic’ I recognise the matters relating to correlation and causation, and the ‘drive’ to publish (and related funding) and its importance. I have not had (made?) time that the report warrants.… Read more »